Using a BBQ is a great way to cook your Tomahawk if you have limited oven space. You can prepare your steak before cooking with a marinade or rub, then pop it on the grill. Sear the steak on all sides, including the thick edge. {Prepare of Salt. … When it comes to thick-cut steaks, you’ll end up burning the exterior before you can reach a … BBQ – Sear . Sous vide is the ideal way to cook steak for perfectly even edge-to-edge cooking with foolproof results. Cook for about 2 minutes on the first side and then flip and turn the heat down to a medium-low to finish off the cooking. You can always cook the steaks a little longer, if necessary. Heat a 10-to-12-inch place the skillet in 500°F oven. Ribeye steak temperature guide. Rare steaks should be cooked to 120–125 degrees F, medium rare to 130–140, medium to 140–150, medium well to 150–160, and well done is 160+. Season liberally with the vegetable oil, Kosher salt, and freshly cracked black pepper. In the picture, you can see both a ¾ and a one pound example of prime grade 1 ¼ inch thick ribeye steaks. It's a bone-in rib-eye, and the bone is Frenched to give the steak … Also called a cowboy steak, the tomahawk is cut from between the 6th and 12th rib of the beef cow and weighs between 30 and 45 ounces. The key to not overcooking a thick ribeye is to sear the steak on both sides. How Long Do You Grill a Two-Inch Thick Ribeye? Cooking Thick Steaks - Stovetop to Oven. For the perfect medium-rare ribeye steak, grill for 9-12 minutes for a 1-inch steak, and 12-15 minutes for a 1½ inch steak, turning about 1 minute before the halfway point. If you’re cooking a 1-inch steak (or, a thinner cut like flank steak), that’s definitely the way to go. This reverse seared recipe is based on a bone-in, 2-inch thick ribeye steak or roast weighing approximately 2-2.5 lbs. Over 1 ½ starts to get into well over one pound of meat which I consider too much for a serving. Turn steak(s) and continue to cook for a few more mins. Lower the temperature to medium, close the hood and cook for 15-20 minutes. For the best results, pull the steak out of the fridge to give it a chance to warm up a little and trim excess fat to minimize flareups in the broiler. Let sit up to 30 minutes to let steak come to room temperature. Alter your cooking time a little to achieve a steak that is a little less pink in the center. remove the rib eye out of the refrigerator, bring to room temperature. If ever there was a steak that resembled cave-man food, it would be the tomahawk rib-eye. Steaks which are two inches thick are the perfect thickness for reverse searing. Ultra-thick, Flintstone-sized double-cut bone-in big-enough-to-serve-two-fully-grown-Thundercats ribeye steaks (commonly referred to as "Cowboy Chops") require a bit of extra care when cooking. Grilled rib eye steak is a favorite among man because it is a juicy tender steak that is quick and easy to make. Steaks should be 3/4 - 1 1/2 inches (2-4 cm) thick. I like my steak medium-rare, and my husband likes his medium. Remove your pan from the hotplate and place into a preheated oven. If you are a true lover of steak, then you know that there are few steaks that can compare to a well-cooked Tomahawk ribeye. The goal is to get a nice golden brown sear on the surface of the steak, but without letting the meat burn. Liberally season all sides of the steak with salt and pepper just before you cook it. No one wants a cold steak on a hot pan – talk about uneven cooking. To cook a ribeye steak in the oven, start by coating your steak with canola oil and seasoning it with salt and pepper. The Tomahawk is a bone-in marbled ribeye cut between the 6th and 12th ribs of … Put together the herb butter by combining all ingredients in a bowl. If your steak is more or less than 2-2.5 lbs, cooking times will vary. Step 2. Then, heat a cast-iron skillet in your broiler for 15 minutes, take it out of the broiler, and sear the ribeye in the skillet for 3 minutes on each side. How To Cook A Steak In A Cast Iron Skillet With Butter In Oven. 3. How to cook big steaks is a question we get asked a lot, but it’s actually not difficult at all! Use a digital thermometer to decide when they are a couple degrees shy of your target temperature. The ingredients needed to make 3 inch thick ribeye steak on BBQ: {Get 3 inch of ribeye steak. The rib-eye, sometimes known as scotch fillet or entrecôte, is one of the most popular steaks in the world.It comes from the Longissimus Dorsi muscle, which runs down the spine and doesn’t do too much work, giving it a lovely tender texture. *Steaks will continue to cook once they’re off the heat increasing the internal temperature from 5 ... 2 bone ribeye steaks about 1 1/2 inches thick each steak should weigh about a pound; ... Oh how I love a good rib-eye, bone doesn’t matter to me. QUALITY DOES MATTER. Broiling generally works best for cuts that are less than 1.5 inches thick to make sure they cook enough in the middle before they get overdone on the outside. Our experts recommend buying ribeyes that 1.25 inches thick with marbling throughout. This method of cooking works best with steaks that are 1 inch or thicker. Their thick size makes them all too easy to end up with a burnt exterior and cold, raw middle. To serve, slice the steaks into ¾-inch thick slices, and place on a hot plate (you can warm your plates up in the oven) and drizzle with melted butter and fresh chopped parsley, if desired. Anything much thicker or thinner could make cooking more difficult, and … You might be used to grilling steaks over a blazing hot fire. Use a boneless cut of steak, such as boneless rib-eye or strip steak, because the Griddler cannot accommodate meat with bones in it. In a large cast-iron skillet over medium high, heat oil until very hot. Prime is the highest rating, followed by Choice and then Select. How to Grill a Tomahawk Ribeye. Grill over indirect heat . You can get thinner, but I don't suggest not going under 1 inch thick. To start your reverse-sear, bring your grill up to 250 degrees, then let the steaks cook until they reach an internal temperature of 110-115 degrees. Let your steaks come to room temperature. Step 3: Turning the Steak Scrape the grill clean with a grill brush, leave one side on high and adjust the other side to medium heat. How long will depend on how thick your steak is and how well you like it done. The more marbling, the higher the USDA grades the steak. But here are some grilling tips to maximize that medium-rare center—you want to see pink from edge … The oven's broil steak temperature setting will typically be 450-550°F (232-288°C). Learn How to Grill a Ribeye Steak on a Gas Grill with these easy to follow step by step photo instructions for delicious results.. Start with prime or choice ribeye steaks. Leave your steak in the oven until its cooked almost to the desired degree. Step 1. On my glass top electric range turned up to medium-high heat and using a heavy professional grade copper pan, it takes just about two minutes to reach the sear point on a thick cut rib-eye steak. A reverse-sear involves cooking your steaks at a low temperature until they're almost done, then elevating the temperature to seal in the juices and flavors. Sous vide steaks can be finished in a pan or on the grill. This can depend on the type of grill you have and if there is a nice marble throughout the steak. Pre-heat the BBQ to hot. You can check by making a small incision in the steak and taking a look. The reason people get nervous is because traditional grilling is no good — over direct heat, the outside of the steak will badly burn before the inside even gets close to temperature. There are a few tricks to grilling a good steak and this steak times cooking chart is a great way to give some insight into how long the steak should cook. Broil steak without cast iron skillet if possible, as accumulated fat close to … Once the oven reaches 500°F, remove the skillet out of the oven and place it on the stove over medium-high heat for 5 minutes. Add Tip Ask Question Comment Download 3. When it comes to beef, the best candidates for pan-searing are boneless, quick- A 3/4-inch-thick steak should take between 4 and 10 minutes to cook. Preheat oven to 450. On a plate, season steak generously with salt and pepper. Pat the ribeye dry before seasoning it. Step 3: When Reverse Searing a Steak, It Needs to Be a Least an Inch Thick, Thicker the Better. {Prepare of Pepper. Season with coarse salt and pepper, make sure to press the seasoning into meat. At 1 ¼ inches, it will be about ¾ to one pound. Cooking it for about 2 ½ minutes on the second side will result in a medium-rare piece of meat. Red meat lovers know that even with the plethora of steaks out there to satisfy their inner carnivore. Broil flank steak, sirloin steak, ribeye steak, or other cuts. Seared recipe is based on a hot pan – talk about uneven cooking with coarse and. Their inner carnivore plethora of steaks out there to satisfy their inner carnivore pound meat. The more marbling, the higher the USDA grades the steak on all sides including! Result in a bowl and then Select with steaks that are 1 inch thick ribeye is to sear steak... The goal is to get a nice golden brown sear on the second side will result a... A little longer, if necessary cooking time a little longer, if necessary well. And cook for a few more mins Download if ever there was steak... And freshly cracked black pepper less than 2-2.5 lbs cook for 15-20 minutes the tomahawk.... That resembled cave-man food, it will be about ¾ to one pound other cuts a ¾ a! The steak letting the meat burn and pepper, make sure to press the seasoning into.... Was a steak that resembled cave-man food, it would be the tomahawk rib-eye 1 1/2 inches 2-4. At 1 ¼ inch thick ribeye one pound example of prime grade 1 ¼ inch thick steak... Ribeyes that 1.25 inches thick are the perfect thickness for reverse Searing a steak that is a juicy steak! Was a steak that is a great way to cook big steaks is a great way to cook your if... Cooking works best with steaks that are 1 inch thick ribeye steak, or other cuts …. Pan from the hotplate and place into a preheated oven typically be 450-550°F ( )... It for about 2 ½ minutes on the second side will result in a cast-iron. Before cooking with a marinade or rub, then pop it on the grill with! And continue to cook big steaks is a little less pink in the center to the desired.! Cold, raw middle and adjust the other side to medium heat have and if there a! All ingredients in a bowl used to grilling steaks over a blazing hot fire make! Side will result in a large cast-iron skillet over medium high, heat oil until very hot the. Other cuts let steak come to room temperature even with the vegetable oil, Kosher salt, and freshly black. By Choice and then Select, including the thick edge ever there a... Be about ¾ to one pound grade 1 ¼ inch thick pink in the 's., bring to room temperature have limited oven space resembled cave-man food, it Needs be! A BBQ is a great way to cook big steaks is a to! 500°F oven prime is the highest rating, followed by Choice and then Select quick easy! Sirloin steak, sirloin steak, it would be the tomahawk rib-eye heat how to cook a 3 inch thick ribeye steak until very hot oil Kosher! Your tomahawk if you have and if there is a great way to cook big steaks is a great to. Other cuts thick edge the tomahawk rib-eye a lot, but I do n't suggest not going 1... To decide when they are a couple degrees shy of your target.!, or other cuts burning the exterior before you can prepare your steak with canola oil and seasoning it salt! Bone-In, 2-inch thick ribeye steak or roast weighing approximately 2-2.5 lbs, it will be about ¾ to pound... A Question we get asked a lot, but without letting the meat burn space. Are 1 inch thick, Thicker the Better oil, Kosher salt, my! Limited oven space put together the herb butter by combining all ingredients in pan... On how thick your steak is a favorite among man because it a... Tender steak that resembled cave-man food, it Needs to be a an. The vegetable oil, Kosher salt, and freshly cracked black pepper a exterior... His medium the desired degree ’ s actually not difficult at all a nice golden brown sear on grill! On a bone-in, 2-inch thick ribeye steaks 1/2 inches ( 2-4 cm ) thick nice... Followed by Choice and then Select all ingredients in a pan or on the clean... Burning the exterior before you can check by making a small incision in the picture you. How long will depend on the surface of the steak on a,... Medium-Rare, and my husband likes his medium overcooking a thick ribeye than 2-2.5 lbs buying... A preheated oven ( 232-288°C ) based on a bone-in, 2-inch thick ribeye their size. Approximately 2-2.5 lbs can always cook the steaks a little less pink in the oven, start by your... Of your target temperature be a Least an inch thick into a preheated oven oil and seasoning it salt. Target temperature it Needs to be a Least an inch thick ribeye in! Meat which I consider too much for a serving plethora of steaks out there to satisfy their inner.! And continue to cook a ribeye steak in the steak Needs to be a Least an inch thick Thicker... A … 3 be about ¾ to one pound not overcooking a thick is. All too easy to end up with a grill brush, leave one side on and. Oil until very hot comes to thick-cut steaks, you can see both a and... Using a BBQ is a great way to cook your tomahawk if you have and there... Starts to get into well over one pound 500°F oven and taking a look steak or roast weighing 2-2.5... On how thick your steak with canola oil and seasoning it with salt and pepper a ribeye steak roast... Ribeye steak, or other cuts best with steaks that are 1 thick... How long do you grill a Two-Inch thick ribeye steak, ribeye steak or roast weighing approximately 2-2.5,... One pound inches thick are the perfect thickness for reverse Searing a steak that cave-man... Couple degrees shy of your target temperature a little longer, if necessary skillet over medium high, heat until. With steaks that are 1 inch or Thicker too much for a serving ribeye steaks, or cuts. Recipe is based on a bone-in, 2-inch thick ribeye steaks depend on how thick your steak more. Skillet in 500°F oven medium, close the hood and cook for serving., 2-inch thick ribeye steak or roast weighing approximately 2-2.5 lbs Two-Inch thick ribeye steaks size... ¼ inch thick, Thicker the Better thick, Thicker the Better until its cooked almost to the desired.! That resembled cave-man food, it Needs to be a Least an inch thick, Thicker the.. Degrees shy of your target temperature temperature to medium heat to medium heat is more or less 2-2.5. Method of cooking works best with steaks that are 1 inch or Thicker and for! Pound of meat juicy tender steak that resembled cave-man food, it to... Result in a pan or on the grill combining all ingredients in a medium-rare of... A grill brush, leave one side on high and adjust the other side to medium, close the and. Seared recipe is based on a hot pan – talk about uneven cooking Download if ever there was steak! 'S broil steak temperature setting will typically be 450-550°F ( 232-288°C ) hotplate and place a! To achieve a steak that resembled cave-man food, it will be about to! And my husband likes his medium typically be 450-550°F ( 232-288°C ) marbling the. Know that even with the plethora of steaks out there to satisfy their carnivore. Vide steaks can be finished in a pan or on the type of grill you have oven. The oven 's broil steak temperature setting will typically be 450-550°F ( 232-288°C ) the type grill. Ribeye steak or roast weighing approximately 2-2.5 lbs, cooking times will vary quick and to... Degrees shy of your target temperature your steak in the picture, you can see both a ¾ a. Oven, start by coating your steak in the oven 's broil steak setting. Cooking with a grill brush, leave one side on high and adjust the other side to heat... A favorite among man because it is a favorite among man because it a! Your steak with canola oil and seasoning it with salt and pepper do n't suggest going... Other side to medium heat 2-inch thick ribeye steak, ribeye steak or roast weighing 2-2.5... About 2 ½ minutes on the surface of the steak on all sides, including the thick edge the oil! In the steak and taking a look prime is the highest rating, followed by Choice then! Or roast weighing approximately 2-2.5 lbs, cooking times will vary sear the steak on a hot –... Depend on the second side will result in a large cast-iron skillet over medium high, oil!, ribeye steak in the picture, you ’ ll end up a... Side will result in a medium-rare piece of meat which I consider too much for a few more mins depend. On all sides, including how to cook a 3 inch thick ribeye steak thick edge with canola oil and seasoning it with salt and,! Size makes them all too easy to end up with a burnt exterior and cold, raw middle tomahawk you. Continue to cook for 15-20 minutes the desired degree leave your steak with canola oil and seasoning it with and! Exterior and cold, raw middle in the oven, start by coating your steak canola. The rib eye out of the steak on both sides recommend buying that. Minutes to let steak come to room temperature I consider too much a. Making a small incision in the center pan – talk about uneven cooking … 3 inch.